Discretionary Commission Arrangements - Complaints and Refunds

Our website uses cookies, to enable essential services and functionality on our site and to collect data on how visitors interact with our site, products and services. By clicking accept you agree to our use of these tools for advertising and analytics and consent to our cookie policy

Advantage Finance: A Deep Dive into the Subprime Lender

Advantage Finance is a prominent player in the UK's non-standard car finance market, specializing in providing Hire Purchase (HP) agreements to customers who may have difficulty securing finance from traditional lenders. This detailed analysis delves into Advantage Finance's background, ownership, financial performance, customer complaints, and public perception to provide a comprehensive overview.

Company Background and Ownership

  • Established Player: Advantage Finance has been operating in the UK motor finance sector for over two decades, building a strong presence in the non-standard market.
  • Solihull-Based: The company is headquartered in Solihull, England.
  • Private Limited Company: Advantage Finance Ltd is a private limited company registered in England and Wales (company number 03773673).
  • FCA Authorization: Advantage Finance is authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), with firm reference number 662067. This authorization allows them to provide consumer credit in the UK.

Financial Performance

  • Limited Public Information: As a privately held company, detailed financial information about Advantage Finance is not readily available. However, some insights can be gleaned from Companies House records:
    • Annual Accounts: The most recent accounts available are for the year ending 31 December 2022.
    • Profitability: While specific figures are not public, Companies House records indicate that Advantage Finance has generally been profitable in recent years.

Customer Complaints and FCA Scrutiny

  • High Volume of Complaints: Advantage Finance has been subject to a significant number of complaints to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS). These complaints often relate to:

    • Affordability: Borrowers complain that Advantage Finance failed to adequately assess their ability to repay loans, leading to financial hardship.
    • High Interest Rates: The high interest rates charged on loans, particularly for those with poor credit, are a common grievance.
    • Debt Collection Practices: Some customers have reported aggressive or unfair debt collection practices.
    • Customer Service: There are concerns about the quality of customer service, including long wait times and unhelpful responses.

  • FCA Investigation into DCAs: Advantage Finance has been involved in the FCA's investigation into Discretionary Commission Arrangements (DCAs). DCAs were a controversial practice where car dealerships could set interest rates on finance agreements, potentially leading to higher rates for customers and increased commission for the dealer. Advantage Finance has acknowledged using DCAs in the past and is cooperating with the FCA's review.

Public Perception and Reviews

  • Mixed Online Reviews: Online reviews of Advantage Finance are mixed. Some customers appreciate the access to finance despite poor credit, while others express dissatisfaction with the high cost of borrowing, customer service, and complaint handling.
  • Trustpilot: On Trustpilot, Advantage Finance has an average rating of 3.8 out of 5 stars. However, it's important to consider that reviews on such platforms may not always provide a complete picture.
  • Reviews.io: On Reviews.io, Advantage Finance has a lower average rating of 2.91 out of 5 stars, with many reviewers expressing negative experiences.

Conclusion

Advantage Finance plays a significant role in providing car finance to individuals with poor credit histories.However, the company has faced criticism and regulatory scrutiny related to affordability assessments, high interest rates, and its past use of DCAs. While Advantage Finance has taken steps to address some of these issues, the volume of complaints and mixed online reviews suggest that there is room for improvement in customer service and complaint handling.

References

This detailed analysis provides a comprehensive overview of Advantage Finance, its operations, and the challenges it faces. By examining the company's background, financials, complaints, and reviews, it aims to offer a balanced and informative perspective for consumers and industry stakeholders.

Advantage Finance and Discretionary Commissions: A Closer Look

Advantage Finance, a significant lender in the UK's non-standard car finance market, has faced scrutiny due to its past involvement in Discretionary Commission Arrangements (DCAs). This practice, now banned by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), allowed car dealerships to influence the interest rates on finance agreements, potentially leading to higher costs for consumers. This detailed analysis examines Advantage Finance's use of DCAs, its response to the FCA's investigation, and the implications for customers.

What are Discretionary Commission Arrangements (DCAs)?

DCAs were a common practice in the car finance industry where dealerships or brokers had the flexibility to set or adjust the interest rate on a customer's finance agreement. The higher the interest rate, the more commission they earned from the lender (in this case, Advantage Finance). This created a conflict of interest, as dealers were incentivized to mark up interest rates to maximize their own profit, potentially leaving customers paying more than they should have.

Advantage Finance and DCAs:

  • Acknowledgement of DCA Use: Advantage Finance has publicly acknowledged that it used DCAs in the past, before the FCA ban came into effect in January 2021.
  • FCA Investigation: Advantage Finance has been part of the FCA's wider investigation into the use of DCAs and their impact on consumers.
  • Cooperation with the FCA: The company has stated its commitment to cooperating fully with the FCA's review and taking appropriate action to address any concerns raised.

Potential Impact on Customers:

  • Overcharged Interest: If a DCA was used in your car finance agreement with Advantage Finance, you might have been charged a higher interest rate than necessary, resulting in you paying more over the life of your loan.
  • Lack of Transparency: DCAs were often not clearly explained to customers, meaning you might not have been fully aware of how the interest rate was determined or the commission the dealer received.

What Can Customers Do?

  • Contact Advantage Finance: If you believe you may have been affected by a DCA, you can contact Advantage Finance directly to discuss your concerns and potential redress.
  • Check Your Finance Agreement: Review your finance agreement for any details about commission or variable interest rates.
  • FCA's Car Finance Complaints Page: The FCA has a dedicated webpage with information about car finance complaints, including those related to DCAs: https://www.fca.org.uk/consumers/car-finance-complaints
  • Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS): If you're unhappy with Advantage Finance's response to your complaint, you can escalate it to the FOS: https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/

Advantage Finance's Response:

  • Commitment to Fairness: Advantage Finance has stated its commitment to treating customers fairly and ensuring they understand the terms of their finance agreements.
  • Redress: While the specific details of any redress scheme are still under review by the FCA, Advantage Finance has indicated its willingness to provide redress to customers who were disadvantaged by DCAs.

Conclusion:

Advantage Finance's involvement in DCAs highlights a broader issue within the car finance industry. While the FCA ban aims to create a fairer and more transparent market, it's crucial for consumers to be aware of the potential impact of DCAs and take steps to protect their interests. By contacting Advantage Finance and understanding their response to the FCA's investigation, customers can gain clarity and potentially seek redress if they were unfairly charged.

References:

Illustration of Fees: 

From 1st March 2022 fees charged by Redbridge Finance will be capped as per the table below. Further examples are shown below the table.

The figures quoted are only calculated on actual money sent to you. If you get a balance reduction, we do not charge any fees on the balance reduction element, just on money sent to you by the lender.

Band

Redress awarded for a claim (£)

The maximum percentage rate of charge

The maximum total charge (£)

1

£1-£1,499

30% plus vat

£420

2

£1,500 - £9,999

28% plus vat

£2,500

3

£10,000-£24,999

25% plus vat

£5,000

4

25,000-£49,999

20% plus vat

£7,500

5

£50,000 or above

15% plus vat

£10,000

These are some examples:

Band 1

Compensation amount £1,000. Our Fee £300 + VAT (£360 inc VAT). You get £640

Compensation amount £1,499. Our Fee £350 + VAT (£420 inc VAT). You get £1,079

Band 2

Compensation amount £5,000. Our Fee £1,400 + VAT (£1,680 inc VAT). You get £3,320 

Compensation amount £9,999. Our Fee £2,083.33 + VAT (£2,500 inc VAT). You get £7,499 

Band 3

Compensation amount £15,000. Our Fee £3,750 + VAT (£4,500 inc VAT). You get £10,500

Compensation amount £24,999. Our Fee £4,166.67 + VAT (£5,000 inc VAT). You get £19,999

Band 4

Compensation amount £30,000. Our Fee £6,000 + VAT (£7,200 inc VAT). You get £22,800

Compensation amount £49,999. Our Fee £6,250 + VAT (£7,500 inc VAT). You get £42,499

Band 5

Compensation amount £50,000. Our Fee £7,500 + VAT (£9,000 inc VAT). You get £41,000

 

Redbridge Finance is Registered in England & Wales with Company Number 10625599. Registered Office: Highfield, Crossing Lane, Claydon, Banbury, OX17 1EX. Redbridge Finance is a Claims Management Company that is Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Firm Reference Number: 836097. VAT Number 270 5830 08. ICO Registration Number ZA533663

 

© 2025 Copyright CarLoanRefunds all rights reserved. Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Pre Contractual Information